Spending more time off road in the RR. So, as you can see the Pirelli Scorpions are not that well suited to mud. General AT3 or Goodyear Duratrac? I will also be using factory 19" not the standard 20" Any thoughts greatly appreciated.

Click image to enlarge

19" had to be duratracs, even though I'm currently on 20" at3 which seemed ok in mud, still reckon the duratracs are better Remember:- amateurs built the ark
Proffesionals built the titanic

You might want to consider the new Pirelli All Terrain Plus.

Have used Duratracs in 255/55R19 on my 2012 WM and now using them in 255/55R20 on my 405. The speed ratings are lower than the Generals I think (19" 112 and 20" 99mph, don't know why different) but not a problem to me in UK. I've been pleased with them off and on road including in wintry conditions. They are the LR homologated off road tyre too.

No experience of the others. Only Range Rovers since 1988

Thanks chaps for your replies, not considered the Pirelli Scorpion All Terrain +. Will have a look.

I have a set of AT+ in 275/55R20 waiting for my noisy BFG KO2 in the same size to wear out. I'm looking for a quieter tyre and someone who fitted a set of AT+ in 275/55R20 to his D5 reports they are indeed quiet on his vehicle. A local farmer recently fitted AT+ in 255/55R19 to his Rok but I have no feed-back from him yet. They have a wide tread which has to help in protecting the sidewalls.

Quite interested to see some reviews of the All Terrain Plus - I’ve used the old ATRs, which seemed a reasonable compromise (if not so great on wet roads). They also have the 3PMSF mark.

Chaps thanks for the insight into the tyre options. I am going to look at both at a local 4x4 tyre dealer in the next week or so to decide. Goodyear v Pirelli.

Another option you could consider is Nokian weatherproof W4 fantastic in the snow wet? you can get them online https://www.tyres-pneus-online.co.uk

I changed from 20" hi-way tyres to 19"Duratrac.They are good in mud and as a allrounder.They are noisy but the extra rubber of the 19" gives an improved ride,even with a A/T tyre! 2012 TDV8 Vogue SE 4.4

Thanks for all you advice and comments. I have decided after viewing and speaking with a couple of D3/Defender owners who use the Duratrac's to go for them. Ordered today and being fitted Monday.

Remember to ensure the tyre speed rating etc is correct for your car - you wouldn't want to invalidate your insurance

Those with L405's, how do you treat the speed ratings? With disdain and hope you don't get found out, or stick to the rules and use what tyre? Not sure any tyre with off road prowess has a >120 mph rating does it?

Happy to be proven wrong as I have STUPID 22's and want to change. 2014 SDV8 L405 Autobiography. Luxor with ivory. 22's...

General Grabber AT3 have an H rating so good for up to 130mph. I have fitted a set on my L405 for the winter. Other all terrain tyres seem to have lower speed ratings so I was not comfortable with them.

Think it should be of less concern to insurers over here now that use of winter tyres is more widespread - the manufacturer-approved brands and sizes generally have lower speed ratings.