Like Craig says i think they are both replica. I have genuine supersport bought from overfinch. On pic 2 the spokes are raised where they meet the outside of the rim. On mine they dont. L405 4.4 SDV8 Santorini/Black VSE
L332 4.4 tdv8 stornoway/Ivory VSE gone
L332 3.6 tdv8 black/sand vogue gone
Mk 7 vw golf r black/black(swmbo)
Mini Cooper s grey gone (swmbo)
BMW e60 m5 black/black gone
BMW e46 m3 silver/black gone
BMW e39 525i m sport blue/sand gone
Vw mk 4 golf gti blue/black gone

[]

Now i'm utterly confused....if you check the photo in the link Craig has provided those wheels also have spokes which are raised where they meet the rim....

Hard to tell properly as looking at link on phone but I don't think they are raised on photo. They meet the rim flush. It is dark now or I would have photographed mine for you.

Have had another look. The spoke is slightly raised in appearance where it meets rim but feels flush at the end if that makes sense. The one on pic 2 looks too pronounced. I have taken photo and will upload from pc L405 4.4 SDV8 Santorini/Black VSE
L332 4.4 tdv8 stornoway/Ivory VSE gone
L332 3.6 tdv8 black/sand vogue gone
Mk 7 vw golf r black/black(swmbo)
Mini Cooper s grey gone (swmbo)
BMW e60 m5 black/black gone
BMW e46 m3 silver/black gone
BMW e39 525i m sport blue/sand gone
Vw mk 4 golf gti blue/black gone

 L405 4.4 SDV8 Santorini/Black VSE
L332 4.4 tdv8 stornoway/Ivory VSE gone
L332 3.6 tdv8 black/sand vogue gone
Mk 7 vw golf r black/black(swmbo)
Mini Cooper s grey gone (swmbo)
BMW e60 m5 black/black gone
BMW e46 m3 silver/black gone
BMW e39 525i m sport blue/sand gone
Vw mk 4 golf gti blue/black gone

m3mjw wrote:

Are these pictures of your wheel? As they are different to the wheel you posted first!


Craig

Alloy No 2 on the OP picture is the same as above with the ridge but does not have Overfinch stamped on the front , on his No1 picture there is no ridge

they are my wheels. to me it looks like wheel 2 in op post has a more pronounced lip where it meets the rim and not original overfinch unless they changed the design slightly. Cant actually beleive i am debating a rim, whats going on with me  L405 4.4 SDV8 Santorini/Black VSE
L332 4.4 tdv8 stornoway/Ivory VSE gone
L332 3.6 tdv8 black/sand vogue gone
Mk 7 vw golf r black/black(swmbo)
Mini Cooper s grey gone (swmbo)
BMW e60 m5 black/black gone
BMW e46 m3 silver/black gone
BMW e39 525i m sport blue/sand gone
Vw mk 4 golf gti blue/black gone

The wheel above looks different to both of the wheels you originally posted? The spoke goes right to the rim on the one above but doesn't on photo 2 in your original post? - do you have 3 different kinds of wheels !? 2003 Vogue 4.4 V8 Java Black

Plus the land rover centre cap in photo 2 looks smaller than the overfinch one above  2003 Vogue 4.4 V8 Java Black

Sorry i appear to have really confused things here. These are not the OP wheels they are mine. I was demonstrating what original overfinch look like. That said you have obviously picked up on the same thing pic 2 in OP would not appear to be gen overfinch due to spokes and centres  L405 4.4 SDV8 Santorini/Black VSE
L332 4.4 tdv8 stornoway/Ivory VSE gone
L332 3.6 tdv8 black/sand vogue gone
Mk 7 vw golf r black/black(swmbo)
Mini Cooper s grey gone (swmbo)
BMW e60 m5 black/black gone
BMW e46 m3 silver/black gone
BMW e39 525i m sport blue/sand gone
Vw mk 4 golf gti blue/black gone

I'd look up this item number on fleabay, it shows very good pictures of "Overfinch replicas" & just how easily they can crack with use & stress. There's also clear photo's of the inside of the rims which should help those who are trying to identify fakes.
Robert.

Fleabay number eBay Item No. 221124966111 The reason women's minds are cleaner than a mans mind is that women change their minds more often!
When women say fine a mans in deep doodoo as fine has so many meanings.