Hi

I am brand new to the forum and the world of Range Rovers so apologies for asking what I imagine is a frequently asked question.

I am thinking boy buying a RR Vogue or possibly a sport around 2018-2020 MY and have read / heard various horror stories about crankshaft failures.

I am looking for any advice on my best option.
Is the TD V6 better than the SD V6 or vice versa. I get the impression most of the crankshaft failures happen on the TD.
Is the 3 litre petrol better than the diesel?
Would I be better with the V8 4.4 diesel which doesn't seem to have the crankshaft issue?

Thanks

I am really wrong person to ask as Petrol all day long for me.

3.0 V6 Supercharged Petrol in Vogue SE spec only and a very capable engine but revs higher than V8 obviously.
5.0 V8 Supercharged Petrol in AB and SV spec only, there are various BHP versions, 510, 525 & 565 depending on Spec and age.

In my view I would always go Petrol but I am bias.

Both Petrol engines will at some point suffer with Timing Chain and guides so buy carefully as always. The key is good and frequent maintenance.

I am sure my Diesel loving friends will be along shortly to put me right.

I suggest you drive both Diesel and Petrol as only you know what will suit your journeys and driving style.

Good luck in what ever you decide, may the fun and games commence.