With regards to the OP's design - if you dont want to muck about cutting and drilling two ally discs, I reckon the top of a 20mm conduit box would be perfect too
http://www.qvsdirect.com/pvc-conduit-box-lid-20mm-black

Thinking about it you can get galv conduit too so there'll be metal lids.. 2007 Vogue TDV8 with 255/55/20's fitted

The Rolls, Bentley Skoda in the door thing is the best option, why would Land rover even think of putting the brolly somewhere where you have to get wet to get to it.

For £18 you can buy small door pocket brollies, they even do a holder that fits below the passengers seat on the L405 and ewok which you can mount in the L322.

have you a link

http://www.lrparts.net/genuine-land-rover-...voque.html

http://www.accessories-landrover.co.uk/lan...1470-p.asp

the seat brolly holder does not look like it would be comfortable

Probably the cheapest, easiest and yet most useful mod I've ever made to the old girl

Go and see your friendly IT department at work and grab two of these

I shall do this mod when I get back into my golf..cracking idea.as an everyday umbrella which is an understatement coming from a wet and windy Edinburgh I've got these in my door pockets for me and any passengers.. fit perfectly and look like they should be there as standard👍