Home > General > Lower mileage 4.2 vs higher mileage 5.0 |
|
|
stan Site Moderator Member Since: 13 Jul 2010 Location: a moderate moderated moderator moderating moderately in moderation Posts: 35280 |
for me yes, the bigger exterior mirrors , the 8 speed box , led lights etc all came into the 'i like it better' equation.. ... - .- -.
|
||
19th Apr 2017 9:06pm |
|
tom0311 Member Since: 16 Apr 2017 Location: Witney Posts: 15 |
Nice feedback MPx. Thanks |
||
20th Apr 2017 7:37am |
|
quavey Member Since: 22 Jan 2017 Location: Lancaster Posts: 302 |
Just to let you know Mike your old 2007 4.2 is currently on Skye after a week of navigation the very north of Scotland.
|
||
20th Apr 2017 9:38pm |
|
MPx Member Since: 29 Jul 2011 Location: South Somerset Posts: 584 |
Good to read Chris - and indeed in other threads about how well you're looking after the old chap - glad its still doing the business. I would say though that your estimated 5k miles a year is looking a bit off. That's over three you've done in less that three months! (Apologies for the hijack Tom....) Mike - MPx
|
||
20th Apr 2017 10:30pm |
|
tom0311 Member Since: 16 Apr 2017 Location: Witney Posts: 15 |
No problem! Good to see a positive report on a 4.2. After more research it looks like that's my most realistic option! |
||
21st Apr 2017 9:37am |
|
XXXAngelXXX Member Since: 25 Mar 2007 Location: Stuttgart Posts: 4994 |
I had both the 4.2 and the 5.0 - go for the 5.0 - it is the more modern car.... All my spelling errorz are belong to me!
|
||
21st Apr 2017 2:24pm |
|
JPHC Member Since: 07 Sep 2015 Location: Kent Posts: 303 |
Had my 4.2 for over a year now. From 40k to 58k.
|
||
22nd Apr 2017 12:37am |
|
tom0311 Member Since: 16 Apr 2017 Location: Witney Posts: 15 |
If I was to buy on condition I think I'll be looking at a low mileage 4.2. The 5.0s in my range really do seem to be the cheapest of that model going. Not sure I'd be comfortable with that, could end up with a pig of a motor. On paper I've had cars quicker than the 4.2 but they've all been saloons with turbos. How does the power of the 4.2 feel? Plenty of torque? Exhilarating? Obviously compared to the 5.0 it's not as fast but and ultimately I'll have to test drive one, just wondering how people would describe it. I had a 2015 C250 merc lease car which was 0-60 in 6 but it delivered the power in a way that felt utterly boring! |
||
22nd Apr 2017 12:33pm |
|
stan Site Moderator Member Since: 13 Jul 2010 Location: a moderate moderated moderator moderating moderately in moderation Posts: 35280 |
the 4.2 is a great choice, might be slightly slower on paper than the 5.0 but in real day terms it doesn't matter...i miss mine as it was so smooth and quiet but i was in a position where i could afford the tdv8 tractor so i went for it..
|
||
22nd Apr 2017 1:29pm |
|
tom0311 Member Since: 16 Apr 2017 Location: Witney Posts: 15 |
I think that's what I'll do unless an amazing cheap 5.0 shows up. Ultimately I'm after a fatty with a supercharged v8 and either will feel like a rocket compared to the 2.7 RRS. |
||
22nd Apr 2017 2:11pm |
|
northernmonkeyjones Member Since: 24 Mar 2012 Location: derby Posts: 8508 |
Night and day with the 2.7.
|
||
22nd Apr 2017 2:55pm |
|
tom0311 Member Since: 16 Apr 2017 Location: Witney Posts: 15 |
Yeah it is pretty pathetic. Once it starts moving it's fine up to 40 then very sluggish. Overtaking uphill is almost embarrassing. I've been sat behind lorries at 40mph uphill on the a34 waiting for a half mile gap to pull out far too many times now. On the plus side it is very comfortable. |
||
22nd Apr 2017 3:56pm |
|
MPx Member Since: 29 Jul 2011 Location: South Somerset Posts: 584 |
Well you wont have that issue in a 4.2. It obviously does kickdown etc as normal, but I found it even more fun to flip the lever over to sport and nudge it down a couple of gears before cracking it open. Very rapid acceleration up or down hill doing that - overtaking is not an issue at all. The 5.0 is quicker, and I like using the flappy things to drop the gears rather than the lever but the 4.2 was more than adequate. You should find it more fun than a laggy turbo saloon, but its no sports car so get it done on the straights and wind your neck back in before the next bends.... Mike - MPx
|
||
22nd Apr 2017 6:55pm |
|
tom0311 Member Since: 16 Apr 2017 Location: Witney Posts: 15 |
More good info thanks fine by me, I'm not a fast driver and all my miles are generally motorway cruising or A-roads so I'm just after straight line power. Sounds like I'll be happy with a 4.2 if that's what's available. |
||
22nd Apr 2017 7:28pm |
|
|
All times are GMT |
< Previous Topic | Next Topic > |
Posting Rules
|
Site Copyright © 2006-2024 Futuranet Ltd & Martin Lewis